November 19th, 2026 | Latest News

HJ Collection administration: Can investors recover their losses from their bank?

Administrators have been appointed over several HJ Collection companies, whose property loan notes were promoted to investors by Hunter Jones. Investors who paid by bank transfer should check whether they may be able to claim reimbursement from their bank, and should act before time limits run out.

The Telegraph has reported that HJ Collection, a property development group whose loan notes were sold to investors through Hunter Jones, has gone into administration. The Times has reported that Steve Illes and Andrew Duncan of MHA have been appointed as administrators over several HJ Collection companies. According to The Times, the administrators were appointed by the scheme’s security trustee, BlueWater Capital, at the request of the group’s founder and director, Reece Mennie.

The collapse follows action by City watchdog, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), the UK’s financial services regulator. On 21 September 2026, the FCA announced High Court proceedings against Osborne Baldwin Limited, which trades as Hunter Jones and Hunter Jones Group. The FCA alleges that Hunter Jones, which sells loan notes, has carried out regulated activity without authorisation. It is asking the Court to stop that activity and to require money to be returned to investors.

Press reports say the FCA’s claim also names Mr Mennie and alleges that the HJ Collection loan notes were operated as a Ponzi scheme. Mr Mennie and his companies deny the allegations and have said they will defend the claim. These remain allegations, the Court has not yet determined the claim, and no final findings have been made.

Reported figures for the size of the scheme differ. The Telegraph has described it as a £300 million scheme, while The Times has described it as a £100 million scheme.

For investors, the pressing question is whether any of their money can be recovered. Where payments were made by bank transfer, one route that may be available is a claim against the investor’s own bank under the authorised push payment (APP) fraud reimbursement rules.


  • Who are HJ Collection and Hunter Jones?

    HJ Collection describes itself as a nationwide property developer, launched by Mr Mennie in 2019 to buy commercial sites and convert them into homes. Companies House records list Mr Mennie as a director of HJ Collection Holdings Ltd.

    Investors typically lent money to HJ Collection companies by buying loan notes. A loan note is usually an agreement to lend money to a company for a fixed period in return for interest, with the original sum repaid at the end of the term. Hunter Jones, the trading name of Osborne Baldwin Limited, promoted these investments.

    Before the administration, investors were reportedly asked to agree to a 12-month delay to repayments of capital and interest. TLW Solicitors has previously reported on the risks of loan notes and mini-bonds, including the FCA’s warning that high fixed returns are a warning sign rather than a guarantee.


  • What is APP fraud?

    APP fraud happens when someone is tricked into sending money by bank transfer to an account controlled by a fraudster. The Payment Systems Regulator (PSR), the regulator for UK payment systems, has introduced rules requiring banks and payment firms to reimburse many victims.

    The PSR’s guidance defines an APP scam as a fraudulent or dishonest act used to manipulate, deceive or persuade someone into transferring money to an account they do not control, where the recipient is not who they intended to pay, or the payment is not for the purpose they intended.

    For an investment, the key question is often whether the money was used for the purpose the investor was told. If investors were told their money would fund property developments, but it was in fact used to pay earlier investors, that may be relevant to a reimbursement claim. Whether that happened in this case has not been established.


  • Could your bank have to reimburse you?

    Since 7 October 2024, banks and payment firms have generally been required to reimburse victims of APP fraud. According to the PSR:

    The main points of the rules are:

    • they apply to payments made on or after 7 October 2024, from one UK account to another by Faster Payments or CHAPS
    • the maximum mandatory reimbursement is £85,000 per claim, although firms may choose to pay more
    • claims should be reported as soon as possible, and within 13 months of the payment
    • firms may apply an excess of up to £100, but not to vulnerable customers
    • a decision should usually be made within five business days, and within 35 business days where the firm needs more information
    • reimbursement can be refused if the customer was complicit in the fraud or grossly negligent, which is a high bar and does not apply to vulnerable customers

    The rules do not cover civil disputes. The PSR describes these as cases where someone pays a legitimate supplier for goods or services that are not received or are defective, with no intent to defraud. Some banks may argue that a failed investment falls into this category.

    However, the PSR’s guidance says that where a bank believes a claim is a civil dispute, the onus is on the bank to show why. It also says that if an investor has received returns, the bank should not conclude for that reason alone that the claim is a civil dispute. This is because in Ponzi-style schemes, early “returns” may be paid from new investors’ money.

    A bank is not automatically responsible for every investment loss. Each claim depends on its own facts, including what the investor was told, how the payments were made and what evidence is available about how the money was used.


  • What if you paid before 7 October 2024 or lost more than £85,000?

    The mandatory reimbursement rules do not apply to payments made before 7 October 2024. That does not necessarily mean there is no route to recovery. From May 2019, many banks signed up to a voluntary code on APP scam reimbursement, known as the Contingent Reimbursement Model Code. Investors may also be able to complain that their bank should have spotted warning signs and intervened before processing large or unusual payments.

    If a bank rejects a complaint, investors may be able to refer it to the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS), a free and independent service that helps resolve complaints between consumers and financial businesses. The PSR says that where more than £85,000 has been lost and not reimbursed, a case can be raised with the FOS, which has a compensation limit of £430,000.


  • Are there other possible routes to recovery?

    The administration process may take time, and it is not yet clear how much, if anything, will be returned to investors through it. Investors should keep all correspondence from the administrators, but may also want to consider other routes alongside it.

    Depending on the circumstances, other parties may need to be considered, such as a regulated financial adviser who recommended the investment, or a pension provider that accepted it into a pension.

    The FCA has also reported that the High Court ordered the winding up of Equity for Growth (Securities) Limited (EFG) on 25 March 2026. It has been reported that EFG acted as principal for Hunter Jones as an appointed representative between 2015 and 2020. Investors who dealt with Hunter Jones during that period may need advice on whether that affects the options available to them.


  • What should HJ Collection investors do now?

    Investors who are worried about their money should act promptly.

    It is important to:

    • contact your bank as soon as possible and report the payments as suspected APP fraud
    • report the matter to Report Fraud, the UK’s national reporting service for cybercrime and fraud
    • contact the FCA at AvillConsumers@fca.org.uk if you invested through Hunter Jones, as the FCA has asked concerned investors to do
    • take advice before agreeing to any changes to your loan notes or signing any new documents
    • seek advice on possible recovery options

    Useful evidence includes:

    • loan note certificates, application forms and investment agreements
    • brochures, adverts, social media posts and projected returns
    • bank statements showing each payment and the account it was sent to
    • emails, messages and notes of calls with Hunter Jones or HJ Collection staff
    • letters about interest payments, repayment delays or the administration
    • details of any adviser, introducer or pension provider involved
    • records of any interest or returns you received

  • Are there time limits?

    Yes. Under the APP fraud rules, claims should be reported within 13 months of the payment. For investors who made payments in late 2025, that window may already be closing.

    Complaints to the FOS must generally be made within six years of the event complained of or, if later, within three years of when the investor knew, or should reasonably have known, they had cause to complain. A complaint must usually be referred to the FOS within six months of the bank’s final response. Court claims are also subject to time limits.

    Investors should not wait for the outcome of the FCA’s case or the administration before taking advice.


  • TLW Solicitors’ comment

    “The administration of HJ Collection will be very worrying for investors, many of whom will want to know whether any of their money can be recovered. The administration process will take time, and it is not yet clear what, if anything, investors will receive from it.

    Investors who paid by bank transfer should not overlook their own bank. Where payments were made after 7 October 2024, the APP fraud reimbursement rules may apply, but claims should be reported within 13 months of the payment. Banks may argue that a failed investment is a civil dispute rather than a scam, so the evidence about how the investment was sold, and what the money was said to be for, needs to be gathered carefully.

    The allegations against Hunter Jones and Mr Mennie have not yet been decided by the Court, and they deny them. Even so, investors should not wait for that outcome before protecting their position. If you invested in HJ Collection loan notes, please gather your paperwork and get in touch with my team to discuss your next steps.”


How TLW Solicitors can help

TLW Solicitors helps people who have lost money through APP fraud, investment scams, bank negligence and failed or unsuitable investment schemes.

If you or a loved one invested in HJ Collection loan notes through Hunter Jones, or in a similar loan note or property investment, we can help you understand whether a claim against your bank or another party may be possible.

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. The law may have changed since publication. Please contact us for advice on your circumstances.

TLW Solicitors can help

It is important to get advice as soon as possible as strict time limits can apply.

You can call us on 0191 293 1500, email us at info@tlwsolicitors.co.uk or complete our online form.

TLW Solicitors pledge

Always fight
your corner

Explain anything you don't understand

Provide full transparency on our charges

Keep your personal information safe

Respond quickly
to any queries